Fish ID from the Maldives

[TheRealChrisBrown]

My inlaws just returned from a 2 week live aboard in the Maldives, 3 deep water dives per day. The took these pictures of a Box Fish, and were having a difficult time finding it's name. If I had to venture a guess it's maybe a juvenile yellow spotted box fish that is transitioning?

These 2 are their pictures of fish in question:

View attachment 16303

View attachment 16302

And this is a pic from the web of what I think the full adult might look like (Ostracion Cubicus):
View attachment 16301

What do you guys think? I know we have some expert fish ID'ers out there!

 

[jda123]

Bottom one is likely a male Ostracion Meleagris - or white spotted boxfish. Females are different. I am no expert, though.

Their patters can be so aberrant and also change from juvi to adult that you might never find out.

 

[MuralReef]

Here is what I found that looked similar, but it is probably a juvenile.
https://reefguide.org/solorboxfish.html

 

[jda123]

https://www.liveaquaria.com/product/77/?pcatid=77

 

[scchase]

Same genus different species top fish is a female adult Ostracion cubicus bottom is a male
Ostracion meleagris

 

[TheRealChrisBrown]

Thank you @jda123 @MuralReef @scchase , I'll let the in-laws know.

They sent me a pic of a powder blue tang and said it was like 12 inches long. I said it looks just like mine....so unless they start having the fish pose next to a beer can I can't trust their size estimates. lol. They do not think I am amusing.

 

[scchase]

Masks make all the fish look bigger though Powder Blues to get to 9" so not too far off with the mask magnification

 

[TheRealChrisBrown]

Masks make all the fish look bigger though Powder Blues to get to 9" so not too far off with the mask magnification

I'm still pushing for beer can sizing pics....