Phosban VS GFO

daverf

Tang
M.A.S.C Club Member
#21
Awesome that you have experience in actually using Lanthanum D&M. Sorry I'm off topic but would be interested to hear if you think it would be worth trying as a sole Phosphate reduction path and just stopping GFO. Maybe I'll PM you about this when I start my phosphate control.
 

ReeferMatt

Nurse Shark
M.A.S.C Club Member
#22
I would be interested to hear more about this product, so feel free to jack this thread!!
 

daverf

Tang
M.A.S.C Club Member
#23
lol...ok, good to hear RefferMatt...i thought you might be interested (which is why I first posted for your thread) but didn't want to assume it was ok to jack! so thanks for confirming.

I believe a lot of people out there use this SeaKlear pool product, but maybe D&M will let us know what he uses.

http://www.poolsonly.com/sea-klear-zero-phos/prod_311.html
 

DyM

Sting ray
M.A.S.C Club Member
#24
SeaKlear pool product is what I use (ordered from Amazon ~$35). The RC threads mention to use the 10 micron, but I decided to be more detailed and use a 5 micron sock. Initially, it clogs up more, but I feel that means it's doing a better job. That's just me. As far as using it as your primary use of PO4 reduction. I think there are folks that do. There was a level of deminishing returns though, meaning it doens't work that great whne phosphates are .08 and lower. There was a lot of chemistry talk to that point but it was way over my head. Lastly, there is a lot of bad info out there - Lanthanum doesn't impact sponges or clean up crew. All of them thrive in my tank. I think it's an issue if you don't use the sock.

My recommendation is if you attack PO4, you have to ensure to address NO3 as well. I have a sulfur reactor, but as with most methods in this hobby, a lot of different options to do the same thing - so I'm not saying use SeaKlear or a sulfur reactor... they both work for me - just know there are more ways to skin the cat.
 

daverf

Tang
M.A.S.C Club Member
#25
wow. excellent to have you share your experience with lanthanum. thanks!
 
Top